An Interesting Question on Garment SAM Calculation and Use of Rating Factor

An OCS reader wrote me following mail. Go through it and try to find out how would you explain him to solve his problem.
"I have a question about calculating SAM for an operation or a garment.

If you use the formula 

Basic time= Observed time * performance rating and use a higher performance rating the time taken for the operation is higher than if you took a lower performance rating that is lower.

For example. observed time is 10 minutes. with this - if the operator is at 100% performance then the operation's Basic time (SAM value) will be 10 minutes (10X1). But if an operator is at 50% performance (meaning half as efficient as an operator at 100% performance) for with the same average time for an operation then basic time is 5 (10 x 0.5)

Is this to mean that a lower operator performance will yield faster completion of garment making tasks? that seems counter intuitive to me. Please explain"

For a while I also started thinking, how it is coming? A higher rated operator taking higher time than the low rated operator. I know it is not true. But where the problem lies in above example? 

I answered him with following explanation.
Don't worry. Just go through following explanation. You will find what is wrong in the above example.

You are going set standard time (SAM) of an operation through time study. First you need to calculate Basic Time. You need to level the observed time (cycle time) to get standard time. And leveling of time is done by multiplying Rating factor (performance rating). 

Formula: Basic time = Observed time X Rating 
(If we do not consider allowances, Basic time=standard time)

Example, You timed one operator and it is 10 minutes, you rate her 50%. As the operator's rating is less than 100%, she would take higher time than the standard time. And standard time would be lower than 10 minutes. Right? 

So you multiply rating with observed time to calculate basic time. And it is (10 * 50%) = 5 minutes. It means an operator who works at normal pace (no too fast or no too slow) should take 5 minute to complete this operation. For same operator, taking 10 minutes to compete that operation and you rate her 100%. Logically, it is not possible. Either you timed wrong or rate her incorrectly.

In reverse way, a 100% operator and a half efficient (50%) operator can not complete a task in same time (10 minutes). Your assumption is wrong in the above example.

Conclusion: A low performance operator would take higher time to complete the given operation than a higher performance operator.

How would you explain the solution? Please add it into the comment box.




5S,3,Activewear,1,Apparel ERP,4,apparel industry,64,apparel news,38,Apparel Production,38,Apparel Software,33,AQL Chart,1,Attachments,1,Bamboo Fabric,1,Bangladesh,4,Blogs,1,Body Scanner,1,Books,35,Business Guides,14,Buyer,4,Buying House,4,CAD/CAM,2,Calculation & Formula,1,career,39,Change Management,1,China,1,Clothing,3,Clothing Brand,6,Compliance,5,Consumption,4,Costing,21,Cutting,25,Data Analysis,2,Defects,6,Denim,11,Directory,3,Drone,1,Dyeing,3,eCommerce,2,Education,5,End use,1,Event & Fair,19,Fabric,92,Fashion,5,Fashion Business,53,Fashion Design,4,Fashion Show,2,Fiber,6,Finishing,14,Fusing,1,Garment Business,3,Garment Exporters,1,Garment Industry,4,Garmenting,2,Gartex,1,GMT,1,GSM,3,Guest Post,7,Heat sealing,1,Human Resource,8,Incentive system,1,Industrial Engineering,258,Industry 4,1,Infographic,5,Inspiration,1,Institutes,1,Interlining,2,Jeans,4,Knitting,5,KPI,10,Kurti,1,Laser Technology,2,Lean,27,Leggings,2,Line Balancing,4,Line layout,6,Living Wages,1,Machines,47,Manufacturing,57,Merchandising,122,MIS,27,MISC,27,Needle,1,News,5,NIFT,4,Operation bulletin,14,Operator,2,Operator Training,4,Performance rating,1,PLM,7,Printing & Embroidery,14,Problem Solving,2,Production Planning,29,Production System,1,Productivity,2,Project Report,1,QNA,138,Quality,76,Quality Circle,1,Quality manual,2,Quality system,16,Research project,5,Resources,46,Retailing,6,RMG,1,Salary & Wages,7,Sampling,27,Scheduling,6,Seam Sealing,1,Sewing Machine,5,Shirt Making,6,Skiiwear,1,skill Matrix,1,Small-scale business,2,Smart Clothing,1,SMV,1,Sourcing,10,Spec Sheet,10,Sportswear,7,Spreading,2,Stitching,4,Store,2,Stretch fabric,1,Student corner,4,sustainable clothing,10,Sustainable Materials,1,T-shirt,5,Tailor,1,Tailoring Shop,3,Technology,95,Texprocess,1,Textile processing,14,Textile testing,25,Textiles,47,Threads,2,Towel,1,Trims & Accessories,19,videos,11,Washing,3,Waste,1,Wearable Tech,2,Work Study,48,Work wear,1,WRAP,1,Yoga wear,1,
Online Clothing Study: An Interesting Question on Garment SAM Calculation and Use of Rating Factor
An Interesting Question on Garment SAM Calculation and Use of Rating Factor
Application of performance rating in SAM calculation using time study method.
Online Clothing Study
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share. STEP 2: Click the link you shared to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy